Sheet 1: 2022 Head turn data was only collected in 2022; thus only n=93. Used for analysis of differences between FC, PC1 and PC2, and for differences in head turn frequency by age. Condition = Condition type (PC1, primed condition 1; PC2, primed condition 2; FC, free condition) PC1 and PC2 were summed due to insignificant differences between them -> PC. Average_Head_turns_per_minute = average number of head turns counted per minute the individual was in camera view For Approaches and Pecks: No = no peck/approach occurred Yes = approach/peck occurred irrespective of colour-match Cor = peck at/approach towards the crisp bag that colour-matched the hand-held one NCor = peck at/approach towards the crisp bag that did not colour-match the hand-held one Both = both colour-matched and non-colour-matched approach/peck occurred Approach_YN and Peck_YN are occurrences of approaches and pecks irrespective of whether they occurred towards the biased side. Sheet 2: 2021 and 2022 summed Combined peck and approach data from 2021 and 2022; thus n=183. Used for analysis of approach and peck occurrence, age differences in approaches and pecks, as well as investigation of whether gull choices matched the hand-held item. Held_Item and Pecked_Item are the colours of the crisp bags (blue and green) held by the experimenter and chosen by the gull, respectively. This was used to test whether Held_Item influenced Pecked_Item. Sheet 3: Directness Scores of directness (1=least, 5=most direct) given by an independent observer.